Mindful Reading

Caution Advisory for Content

There are four levels/categories of rating that a book receives based on its content. The rubric used to make this decision consists of four sub-categories as listed below.
Subcategories (0-5 rating)
Profanity
Violence (suicide and sexual harassment included)
Sexual content/Nudity (sexual innuendo included)
Mature Themes (pre-marital relations, LGBTQ+)

After rating these sub-categories, we arrive at a categorical content rating as a caution advisory. Our updated content rating now has four, instead of three, categories.These reflect the level of caution advised when considering reading a book based on the degree of clean content or lack thereof.

After rating these sub-categories, we arrive at a categorical rating for the clean content as explained here:

None

A book receives this rating if there is no swearing, no gory violence, no premarital relations and no sexual references. In other words, as halal as a story can be.

Medium

A book which has light swearing, minimal violence, pre-marital relations but no explicit sexual descriptions is categorized as medium level.

High

A book with High caution advisory contains some swearing, violence, pre-marital relations and indirect sexual descriptions (some innuendo, closed door relations).

1

Extreme

If there is lots of swearing/profane language, sexually explicit descriptions ( open-door relations), LGBTQ+ content in a book, it receives an Extreme rating.

A caution meter displays this level of caution advised. Additionally, we also list an advisory for the content that might not be clean when a ‘Medium’ or ‘High’ caution rating book is reviewed so readers can decide whether to skip the book or the specific parts if permitted. Books with ‘Extreme’ caution advisory are not reviewed.

Recommendations

Book Review Ratings

The reviews include a point rating (out of five) and get a corresponding category label as well as explained in the rubric below (e.g., a book with 5/5 rating will be labeled a ‘Recommended’ book). The scale is not a regular interval scale as we at The Book Sieve believe that how we feel about a book does not follow a linear pattern.

Book review rubric
Category rating Point rating (out of five)
Recommended 4-5
Feel Good 3-3.9
Okayish 1.6-2.9
Pass this one 0-1.5
Scroll to Top

Book Reviews, Clean Ratings & Book Blogs

© 2022 A. booksieve. All rights reserved.